Customer Service 1 (888) 261-2693
Advanced Search

The Mining Stocks You DON'T Want to Own Today

By Brian Weepie, analyst, Stansberry Research Resource Report
Wednesday, March 4, 2015

Last year, we told you about the terrible bear market in iron ore.
 
Iron ore, the building block for steel, fell 67% over the past four years... and 44% in the past year alone. Many iron ore miners are down double digits.
 
But there's likely even more downside ahead...
 
As regular Growth Stock Wire readers know, commodities like iron ore are tremendously cyclical. That means their prices go through big cycles of boom and bust. That's because the prices of commodities are based (almost) solely on supply and demand. If there's more supply than demand, prices will fall. But if there's more demand than supply, prices will rise.
 
So with a global oversupply of iron ore and a slowdown in demand from places like China, which is a huge consumer, iron ore prices have been in "bust" mode for the past few years.
 
As you can see in the chart below, iron ore prices are now near their 2009 low.
 
 
The big decline sent the share prices of iron ore miners down as well.
 
Shares of BHP Billiton, the world's largest iron ore miner by market cap, are down around 25% over the past year. Meanwhile, Rio Tinto, the world's second-largest iron ore producer, is down around 15%.
 
Giant Brazilian iron ore producer Vale is down around 50%. And Australian iron ore miner Fortescue Metals Group and U.S. producer Cliffs Natural Resources are down around 54% and 65%, respectively, during the same time frame.
 
But shares of these companies are likely headed even lower...
 
Despite global oversupply and falling prices, the world's largest producers of iron ore – BHP Billiton, Rio Tinto, and Vale – are not cutting back production.
 
Instead, they're ramping it up.
 
In January, Brazil's iron ore exports hit a nine-year high due to Vale's increased production.
 
Meanwhile, BHP Billiton has increased its iron ore production by 16% this year. And Rio Tinto's global iron ore production will rise 12% this year.
 
You see, while iron ore prices may be near their 2009 low – at around $60 per ton – they're still well above the cost of production for Rio Tinto, BHP Billiton, and Vale.
 
Producer
Production Cost (per ton)
Iron Ore % of Total Revenue
Rio Tinto
$17
46%
BHP Billiton
$20
32%
Vale
$47
74%
Fortescue Metals Group
$41
100%
Cliffs Natural Resources
$58
85%

So Rio Tinto, BHP Billiton, and Vale still have solid profit margins on the iron ore they're producing. Importantly, these companies also don't rely on iron ore for 100% of their total revenue.
 
Meanwhile, higher-cost producers that rely on iron ore for the majority of their revenue, like Fortescue Metals Group and Cliffs Natural Resources, are seeing their profit margins and total revenue shrink.
 
With iron ore prices falling, there has been pressure on Rio Tinto, BHP Billiton, and Vale to cut back their production – similar to the pressure being put on Saudi Arabia to cut oil production and prop up the oil price.
 
But like Saudi Arabia, they're refusing.
 
Rio Tinto's CEO, Sam Walsh, said in a company release that if Rio Tinto cut supply, higher-cost producers would simply fill in. He believes that lower prices will force out higher-cost competition in the sector.
 
"Now I know there are some people hanging on by their fingernails," Walsh said recently in a company report. "You can only do that for a certain time and sooner or later you've got to recognize the reality of life."
 
In short, the big miners are trying to push some of their higher-cost competition out of business by squeezing their profit margins. When these producers leave the sector, iron ore production will fall... and prices will increase when the supply/demand gap starts to close.
 
But for this to happen, iron ore prices – and the share prices of iron ore producers – have to continue to fall.
 
So, the bear market in iron ore continues... For now, stay away from iron ore miners.
 
Good investing,
 
Brian Weepie




Further Reading:

"Mining can be a risky business," Matt Badiali writes. "Finding, building, and operating a mine is tough." But Matt says there's one type of "mining" stock that allows you to participate in the natural resource sector with far less risk and big upside potential. Get all the details here.
 
Matt says investors also shouldn't bank on higher oil prices... and that means there's likely more downside ahead for oil stocks. Learn why right here.

Recent Articles
Market Notes
Satellite radio provider Sirius climbs to a fresh 52-week high.
 
Wheat prices are falling... down more than 15% in two months.
 
Electric-car maker Tesla is down nearly 30% in six months.
 
Garbage collector Waste Management soars 30%-plus over the past year.
From The Crux
Market Watch
Symbol Price
Change
52-Wk
S&P 500 2104.33 -0.6% +14.0%
Oil (USO) 18.54 +1.2% -50.6%
Gold (GLD) 115.60 -0.1% -11.3%
Silver (SLV) 15.59 -0.5% -24.4%
U.S. Dollar 95.22 -0.3% +18.9%
Euro 1.12 +0.2% -18.4%
Volatility (^VIX) 14.51 +11.3% -9.3%
Gold Stocks (^HUI) 184.70 -1.3% -23.6%
10-Year Yield 2.09 +0.5% -19.9%

World ETFs
Symbol Price
Change
52-Wk
India (IFN) 29.95 +0.2% +57.2%
China (FXI) 42.61 -2.8% +25.2%
Taiwan (EWT) 15.91 -0.6% +16.7%
USA (SPY) 210.48 -0.7% +16.0%
S. Africa (EZA) 67.35 -0.6% +12.1%
Japan (EWJ) 12.29 -0.7% +9.8%
Singapore (EWS) 12.77 +0.0% +5.3%
Israel (ISL) 16.77 +0.0% +0.7%
Canada (EWC) 27.91 -0.4% -2.0%
S. Korea (EWY) 57.30 +0.4% -4.3%
Lat.America (ILF) 31.09 -0.1% -4.6%
Russia (TRF) 9.84 +0.1% -19.8%

Sector ETFs
Symbol Price
Change
52-Wk
Semis (PSI) 27.38 -1.9% +40.4%
Transportation (IYT) 162.11 -0.9% +24.7%
Health Care (IYH) 152.27 -1.3% +23.6%
Retail (PMR) 40.13 -0.5% +22.0%
Big Tech (QQQ) 108.37 -0.9% +22.2%
Biotech (PBE) 54.22 -1.2% +20.8%
Real Estate (IYR) 78.89 -0.7% +20.0%
Consumer Svcs (IYC) 144.97 -0.6% +19.6%
Defense (PPA) 36.98 -0.9% +14.4%
Financials (IYF) 89.84 -0.7% +14.9%
Utilities (XLU) 44.36 +0.0% +14.7%
Software (PSJ) 41.62 -1.1% +12.3%
Industrials (IYJ) 110.11 -0.9% +11.6%
Insurance (IAK) 49.38 -0.6% +11.9%
Telecom (IYZ) 30.86 -0.2% +9.5%
Basic Mat (IYM) 86.08 -0.7% +6.2%
Media (PBS) 26.72 -0.6% +3.1%
Construction (PKB) 23.17 -0.7% +1.3%
Water (PHO) 25.32 -0.8% -3.8%
Alt. Energy (PBW) 5.49 -1.4% -22.8%