Customer Service 1 (888) 261-2693
Advanced Search

A Timeless Lesson on Investing With the Government

By Brian Hunt, Editor in Chief, Stansberry Research
Monday, February 11, 2013

Sometime in the past decade, Americans who should know better embraced a horrible investment idea...
 
If you've ever bought a stock because an investment guru told you it was "state owned" and backed by the government, chances are good you fell for a common mistake... And chances are good you lost money on the deal.
 
In today's essay, I'll show you why this is the case... and why you should always be leery of investing with "state owned" companies.
 
To drive the point home, we'll look at a poster child of "state owned" investing – Brazil's oil firm, Petrobras. It's a popular stock among investment advisors and fund managers. If you watch a financial television program about "investing around the globe," you'll probably hear someone gushing about Petrobras and its "state owned" status. After all, how could you go wrong partnering up with the national government?
 
Answer: very easily.
 
Below is a two-year chart of Petrobras. It tracks shares from early 2011 through 2012. They've plummeted from $40 per share to $17 per share... a loss of 57%. This horrific performance was produced in a rising oil price environment. During the same period, other "Big Oil" companies like ExxonMobil and Chevron registered gains.
 
Petrobras (PBR) Has Plummeted In Recent Years
 
How could the "experts" be so wrong about Petrobras? How could investors in a big "state backed" company get killed while investors in regular oil companies did well? It's easy to explain. But we have to leave investment La La Land and remember how things work in the real world...
 
Remember how your average government agency works (or doesn't work). The bureaucrats running government agencies are not incentivized to produce profits. They are not incentivized to improve the long-term value of a business. Bureaucrats are incentivized to spend their entire budgets and grow larger. This allows them to acquire more power... and bigger budgets for next year... which allows them to acquire more power and bigger budgets for the year after that.
 
Compare this to an entrepreneur who has his own money on the line. He's going to do his best to keep costs down, instead of intentionally blowing his budget. He's going to do his best to hire only employees he needs... rather than hire as many people as possible. He's going to keep a close eye on his cash flow, or he'll go broke.
 
Most smart people know this is the difference between government and business. But when it comes to investment, even "small government" republicans and libertarians lose their minds and line up to buy shares in inefficiently managed, state-owned companies. It defies belief. They'd be better off partnering up with a crack addict.
 
As for Petrobras, the company has phenomenal assets. It controls some of the biggest untapped oil fields on the planet. But they are offshore oil fields. Developing them will cost enormous amounts of money. That's why the company has trumpeted its planned $200 billion-plus capital-spending plans. It's believed to be the biggest corporate-expenditure program in the world.
 
This absurdly large amount of spending will be overseen by bureaucrats. Take a guess on how that will turn out. While you're forming your guess, remember that if an entrepreneur opened a lemonade stand, he would work by himself and turn a profit. If a government opened a lemonade stand, it would have a dozen employees and go broke in three months.
 
Don't get me wrong: I'm not saying you should never buy shares in a state-owned company. They can work out as trades. Also, I'm not saying all government is bad. I'm not saying government employees are horrible people. Save your hate mail.
 
But just remember what happens with most every government agency or program. They are not run for a profit. They are not incentivized to keep costs down. They are incentivized to grow bloated and inefficient.
 
The next time you're considering "partnering up with a government" – and buying a state-owned company – remember how government works.
 
You'll probably do better with a lemonade stand.
 
Regards,
 
Brian Hunt
 
P.S. About 10 days ago, I attended the Orlando MoneyShow. It's a huge conference where financial services providers try to drum up new business. Petrobras was one of the few large public companies that sent a team of "representatives" to the conference. I'm sure the trip cost shareholders tens of thousands of dollars (maybe hundreds of thousands). There was no team from ExxonMobil or Chevron.




Further Reading:

Read more timeless investing wisdom here...
 
Sometimes, all you need to do to profit is "act dumb"...
 
"You're better off taping the Wall Street Journal's stock table to the wall, throwing darts at it, and buying the stocks you hit..." 
 
"Anyone who took our advice has saved – and made – a lot of money over the past few years."

In The Daily Crux
Market Notes
Health care stocks are booming... big fund XLV is up 40% over the past two years.  
 
"Big Tech" is working on an uptrend... sector fund QQQ touches a three-month high.  
 
The uranium market is breaking out... Uranium Participation Corp. is sitting at a six-month high.  
 
Coal companies are still struggling... Peabody and Arch Coal break down to three-month lows.
Market Watch
Symbol Price
Change
52-Wk
S&P 500 1520.33 +0.1% +12.5%
Oil (USO) 35.19 -0.3% -9.1%
Gold (GLD) 159.05 -0.5% -5.1%
Silver (SLV) 29.77 -1.1% -9.1%
U.S. Dollar 80.08 +0.0% +1.4%
Euro 1.35 +0.3% +2.3%
Volatility (^VIX) 12.98 +2.7% -31.8%
Gold Stocks (^HUI) 390.72 -1.9% -25.1%
10-Year Yield 2.02 +2.0% +1.5%

World ETFs
Symbol Price
Change
52-Wk
USA (SPY) 152.15 +0.1% +14.9%
Singapore (EWS) 13.90 +0.3% +13.6%
Israel (ISL) 14.04 +0.6% +7.7%
Japan (EWJ) 10.04 -0.4% +5.3%
Canada (EWC) 28.97 -0.1% +5.2%
China (FXI) 40.05 +0.6% +4.4%
Taiwan (EWT) 13.60 +0.1% +4.0%
S. Korea (EWY) 60.57 +1.3% +3.6%
India (IFN) 21.50 -0.9% +2.8%
S. Africa (EZA) 67.81 +0.3% +2.6%
Russia (TRF) 15.75 +0.9% -2.4%
Lat.America (ILF) 44.55 -1.0% -5.7%

Sector ETFs
Symbol Price
Change
52-Wk
Construction (PKB) 19.26 +0.8% +39.5%
Media (PBS) 17.87 +0.5% +24.3%
Consumer Svcs (IYC) 93.39 +0.2% +23.4%
Health Care (IYH) 90.40 +0.0% +22.4%
Financials (IYF) 66.00 -0.2% +22.3%
Insurance (PIC) 19.45 +0.2% +21.5%
Water (PHO) 22.60 +0.8% +18.7%
Real Estate (IYR) 68.40 0.0% +15.6%
Telecom (IYZ) 24.81 -0.3% +15.2%
Industrials (IYJ) 79.68 +0.6% +14.9%
Retail (PMR) 26.63 +0.2% +13.0%
Transportation (IYT) 105.49 +0.4% +12.2%
Defense (PPA) 21.77 -0.2% +11.2%
Software (PSJ) 28.64 -0.4% +10.1%
Utilities (XLU) 36.94 +0.0% +9.6%
Big Tech (QQQQ) 67.97 +0.4% +9.2%
Biotech (PBE) 24.81 +0.7% +9.1%
Basic Mat (IYM) 72.09 +0.3% +2.0%
Nanotech (PXN) 6.50 +0.8% -1.3%
Semis (PSI) 15.37 +0.1% -2.2%
Alt. Energy (PBW) 4.64 +0.2% -22.4%

Recent Articles