Customer Service 1 (888) 261-2693
Advanced Search

Why China's Real Estate Market Won't Collapse

By Frank Curzio, editor, Phase 1 Investor
Wednesday, September 22, 2010

What's the one industry you would avoid in China?
During my trip to China last month, I met with several portfolio managers and investment analysts. I was looking for small-cap investment ideas with huge upside potential. We heard about several promising sectors, including alternative energy, pollution control, health care, and fertilizers.
But at the end of each conversation, I asked these investment professionals the question above. Without hesitation, every one said real estate was their biggest concern. Most believe China's real estate market will suffer a fate similar to real estate in the U.S. – a 30%-plus decline in the average home price.
Over the past few years, the average home price in China roughly doubled. That's about the same percentage home prices gained from 2003 through 2006 in many areas across the U.S.
Looking at that huge jump – which was even higher in areas like Beijing and Shanghai – I can see the bearish side. But before you look for ways to short China's real estate market, let's take a look at the bigger picture...
For one, the fact that prices are rising does not make housing or any particular stock expensive. China's economy has grown at an average annual rate of 9.5% over the past 10 years. That's about four times the rate of the U.S. With an economy growing this fast, it should come as no surprise that home prices are surging.
Another point to consider... There is no subprime market in China.
In the U.S., just about anyone who could fog a mirror walked away with a $350,000 mortgage – and a "teaser" interest rate set to explode in a few years. When home prices fell, homeowners walked away from their mortgages and foreclosures skyrocketed. The huge increase in inventory crushed the market. Four years later, U.S. real estate is still struggling to find a bottom.
That won't happen in China. The government requires down payments of 30% for new home buyers. For a second home, the down payment is 50% to 60%. These large down payments will prevent homeowners from walking away from mortgages if the real estate market falls 10% to 20%.
And let's say prices do fall 20%... China's savings rate is over 30%, compared to about 6% in the U.S. In other words, China has plenty of cash to buy real estate on a pullback. That creates a floor of value.
In some of the more heavily populated cities – like Beijing and Shanghai – where home prices are now well above affordability levels, the government is requiring even higher down payments, adding new property taxes, and forcing banks to set aside more deposits as reserves.
Imagine if the U.S. had initiated similar policies in 2005... I'd bet the housing market would be on much better footing today.
As I mentioned earlier, every person I talked to in China believes the housing market is overvalued. In fact, I don't know one person living anywhere who believes China's property market is a buy.
That gives me even more conviction the decline in the industry won't be a sudden freefall. As for those who are predicting a U.S.-type 35% collapse in property prices, I just don't see it.
Good investing,

Recent Articles
Market Notes
The "Google of China," Baidu, hits all-time high... Google itself jumps 8% in less than a week.
Big telecom and wireless companies dominate 52-week highs list, Siemens and China Unicom included.
Asia up… Hong Kong, Singapore, Malaysia, and India funds sitting within 1% of new highs.
Machinery makers Caterpillar, Cummins, and Joy Global reach new highs.
Market Watch
Symbol Price
S&P 500 1134.28 -0.5% +5.8%
Oil 32.58 -0.2% -11.9%
Gold 126.20 +0.2% +26.6%
Silver 20.71 +0.6% +22.7%
US-Dollar 79.77 -0.8% +4.8%
Euro 1.34 +1.0% -9.4%
Volatility 22.51 +0.7% -2.5%
Gold Stocks 509.86 +1.0% +19.2%
10-Year Yield 2.55 -1.5% -26.3%

World ETFs
Symbol Price
USA 113.42 -0.5% +5.9%
Canada 27.49 -0.8% +5.6%
Russia 19.10 +0.4% +0.8%
India 36.14 -1.9% +25.2%
Israel 15.89 +0.2% +13.5%
Japan 9.78 -0.3% -4.1%
Singapore 13.04 +0.1% +20.7%
Taiwan 13.21 -0.3% +8.1%
S. Korea 52.41 +0.1% +10.2%
S. Africa 65.01 +0.5% +14.7%
China 42.21 -0.6% -2.2%
Lat.America 48.65 +0.5% +14.1%

Sector ETFs
Symbol Price
Oil Service 108.69 -0.5% -9.9%
Big Pharma 65.00 +0.2% +0.2%
Internet 62.54 -0.3% +23.1%
Semis 12.30 -2.6% -4.6%
Utilities 31.32 +0.7% +6.3%
Defense 17.03 -0.7% +3.9%
Nanotech 8.76 -0.5% -21.1%
Alt. Energy 9.29 -0.5% -17.9%
Water 16.17 -0.4% -6.3%
Insurance 15.27 -1.2% +11.5%
Biotech 19.05 -0.4% +10.9%
Retail 17.04 -0.4% +8.1%
Software 22.17 -1.5% +15.2%
Big Tech 48.69 -0.3% +14.2%
Construction 11.65 -0.7% -6.3%
Media 11.98 -1.9% +11.8%
Consumer Svcs 60.32 -0.5% +14.0%
Financials 52.45 -1.5% -3.0%
Health Care 63.14 +0.0% +6.4%
Industrials 57.61 -0.6% +11.5%
Basic Mat 64.21 +0.4% +12.0%
Real Estate 53.78 -1.0% +19.4%
Transportation 81.01 -0.9% +12.8%
Telecom 21.59 -0.6% +15.6%

In The Daily Crux